| Autor | Mensaje | Me gustas | Fecha |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rafa_Bernabe |
Re: By the way, Jesús
Me reafirmo en las felicitaciones.Le pase al artículo de los px a Joaquin Gálvez,que daba un sus cursos una cata... |
- | 18/05/04 22:17 |
| Erre |
By the way, Jesús
Ya que te veo por aquí no quiero dejar pasar la ocasión de felicitarte por tu ya ;clásico; trabajo en elmundovino... |
- | 18/05/04 22:05 |
| JesusBSanz |
Re: Entrevista a Jancis Robinson
Gracias por el soplo. Ahora mismo no tengo tiempo de leer el texto despacio, pero mi primera impresión es que la... |
- | 18/05/04 21:42 |
| Rafa_Bernabe |
Entrevista a Jancis Robinson
Para los amantes de esta maravilla de nariz.Y de mujer.http://www.acenologia.com/investigacion_entrevista66_1.htm |
- | 18/05/04 20:56 |
| Bosco |
Re: Thur solo tienes que mandarme un correo y sin problemas eh¡
A la derecha del Dios Padre amigo, un abrazo, las cepas, Thur las cepas del Pena a la primera de cambio al Gonzalo... |
- | 07/05/04 22:57 |
| rania |
Jancis Robinson catará Priorats 2001
Jancis Robinson está organizando una importante cata de Priorats 2001, enmarcada en la feria Wine&Spirits de... |
- | 06/05/04 19:21 |
| jose |
Gasp... For me a wine scored with a 6/10 is..
...A wine I wouldn´t drink again neither for free! :-P Cheers, Jose |
- | 24/04/04 19:06 |
| MaJesus |
Re: The 20 point rating system
In most TN’s that I read on the 20 point scale (admitely not that many: some in ;el mundo vino; and in Vinum;, I... |
- | 24/04/04 18:32 |
| jose |
You’re gettin’ older and a bit of reality bites, Gasty ;
(V) |
- | 21/04/04 22:19 |
| WaltZalenski |
Re: BTW, this TN resembles the Sot Lefriec 2000...
;Too explosive to eat with ANY food; I tried Sot Lefriec dining outdoors in Barcelona during the Summer heatwave... |
- | 20/04/04 17:48 |
| WaltZalenski |
Re: I liked AN/2 too...
Tried it last night. Not bad at all. I still want some 2001 AN, which I had in Spain but has been unavailable here. |
- | 20/04/04 17:41 |
| MCamblor |
Re: A 12/20 rating is a barely above average wine
See? That’s what I hate about scores... ;Above average?; What’s that, grading on a perverse curve? I remember back... |
- | 20/04/04 15:34 |
| Juan Such |
Wine rating is not an exact science...
Well, after reading something from Coates I’m now not so sure about the equivalence of the 20 point system from... |
- | 20/04/04 13:55 |
| Juan Such |
The 20 point rating system
The 20 point rating system is quite extended around Europe. It’s employed, among others, by the ’Vinum’ magazine... |
- | 20/04/04 13:47 |
| Gastronauta |
Re: drama
What do you mean tongue-in-cheek? I LIVE tongue-in-cheek ;^) I enjoy the exchange, that’s all. In my own... |
- | 20/04/04 11:50 |
| WaltZalenski |
Re: A 12/20 rating is a barely above average wine
Juan, you may be correct that, at least theoretically in Parker’s scoring scheme, an 80 point wine may have no... |
- | 20/04/04 05:27 |
| MCamblor |
Re: That’s what her scores say...
Ah, scores... Don’t care for them, don’t look at them, tend not to notice them even when they’re thrust in my face.... |
- | 20/04/04 02:34 |
| Juan Such |
BTW, this TN resembles the Sot Lefriec 2000...
...I tasted the last week. Too explosive to eat with ANY... |
- | 20/04/04 01:31 |
| Juan Such |
But you will be happy with her Marojallia TN...
Enjoy :-): LEFT BANK Marojallia 2003 Margaux 15.5 Drink: 2010-16 ;Very deep purple, very right bank (the... |
- | 20/04/04 01:24 |
| Juan Such |
That’s what her scores say...
Manuel, her scores (out of 20) are very clear: 18,5 (the maximum she awards, except for the 19/20 for the Ch.... |
- | 20/04/04 01:16 |
| MCamblor |
Liked?
Don’t know, are you reading something else you didn’t post, Juan, or have you upped your meds again without my... |
- | 20/04/04 00:58 |
| Juan Such |
I liked AN/2 too...
I am starting to worry about our coincidence in wine appreciation. I must be getting old.. :-) I loved that 2001... |
- | 20/04/04 00:38 |
| Juan Such |
Just for the record, Jancis liked the Valandrauds
I don’t think is just a problem of style. She didn’t like THAT wine. For the record I copy her three comments about... |
- | 20/04/04 00:21 |
| WaltZalenski |
An/2
; I was pleasantly surprised by a bottle of the bodega’s ;AN/2,; with its cool, minimalist (some would say slightly... |
- | 20/04/04 00:15 |
| Juan Such |
A 12/20 rating is a barely above average wine
Just two comments, Walt: ;Mrs Robinson gave the wine a score that denotes a technically defective wine; A 12/20... |
- | 20/04/04 00:13 |
| MCamblor |
Who ya callin' "crusty?"
So sorry, Walt... Never had a crust on me. We Cubans of a certain extraction and persuasion have a thing for... |
- | 19/04/04 23:54 |
| WaltZalenski |
Manuel fights for
;Oh, and should Mrs. Robinson ever need an army (or at least a gang) to help her fight her battles, I will be first... |
- | 19/04/04 22:59 |
| MCamblor |
Other people’s money...
Drama... That’s a funny word. In case you didn’t notice, there was quite a bit of tongue-in-cheekness in my three... |
- | 19/04/04 21:26 |
| Gastronauta |
Re: CiviliWHAT???!!! Allrightallrightallright__ ;^)
But that was (part of) my point, you see. I mean this is --like it or not-- the direction things are heading for.... |
- | 19/04/04 18:06 |
| MCamblor |
CiviliWHAT???!!!
Gastro, PLEEEEAAASE!!! In fun or not, calling the forces that are indeed conspiring against all that is decent, nice,... |
- | 19/04/04 16:16 |
| MCamblor |
Hedging...
It seems to me, dear Walt, that Mrs. Robinson’s distinguished FT partner is hedging his bets a little. Indeed, he... |
- | 19/04/04 16:02 |
| Gastronauta |
Right to opinion
Sure, everybody has one, but then comes the moment to defend it. In this case Jancis has thrown a gauntlet she cannot... |
- | 19/04/04 15:12 |
| WaltZalenski |
Re: Some further reflections...
I have to say, Manuel, that I am all but completely agnostic about this issue. I wasn’t at this Bordeaux en primeurs... |
- | 19/04/04 08:59 |
| THuRStoN |
Re: Sin duda, que todo el apoyo a Jancis!!!
Dile que se venga a catar con la Peña Bilbao :^), que va a aprender mucho :-))) THuRStoN^Peña Bilbao |
- | 19/04/04 00:38 |
| Bosco |
Re: Sin duda, que todo el apoyo a Jancis!!!
Thur la semana proxima como con ella y le dare un recado de tu parte amigo, un abrazo |
- | 18/04/04 21:41 |
| THuRStoN |
Sin duda, que todo el apoyo a Jancis!!!
Yo estoy 100% en su linea, no he catado el vino en cuestión pero el ataque directo de mr. CENSORED está fuera de... |
- | 18/04/04 21:10 |
| MCamblor |
Some further reflections...
There are two things about Mr. Parker’s anti-Jancis comments that have bothered me ever since I posted the reply to... |
- | 18/04/04 03:19 |
| MCamblor |
Of course, you know which side I will take...
I would say that Jancis is worthy of great respect for telling it like it is--for her. She dares to express a strong... |
- | 17/04/04 23:30 |
| jose |
Me cae de un bien Jancis, "que pa qué" :) (v)
(V) |
- | 17/04/04 22:47 |
| Juan Such |
Robinson y Parker sobre el Chateau Pavie 2003
Ya te he contestado en el foro en inglés pero pongo aquí también la respuesta para los que no lo visitan. Bien, todo... |
- | 17/04/04 22:43 |
| Juan Such |
Re: Robinson & Parker on Pavie 2003
Well, the Decanter article gives the basic information. The Jancis Robinson tasting note about the 2003 Château Pavie... |
- | 17/04/04 22:35 |
| jose |
Parker & Robinson, maybe two sides of...
(Maybe even) a (different) coin.Hi all,Does anybody have more info about... |
- | 17/04/04 19:51 |
| jose |
Parker & Robinson... como que muy de acuerdo no están...
http://www.decanter.com/news/48406.html¿Alguien tiene más info?Saludos,Jose |
- | 17/04/04 19:49 |
| Jose Contreras |
Re: Cata con jancis robinson alimentaria 2004
Carlos, es una pena que no coincidiéramos por allí para haber tomado algo juntos y charlar un rato. A la próxima será. |
- | 16/03/04 12:55 |
| Carloyo |
Cata con jancis robinson alimentaria 2004
Elpasado viernes dentro de las actividades progamadas por vinorum para este salon acudimos a las 11.30h a una... |
- | 15/03/04 21:46 |
| MaJesus |
Re: Jolin 40 euros ...
Gracias Victor, y descuida, que aviso, aviso ... si es lo único que me consuela, ver a los fantásticos Bcneses! (y... |
- | 04/03/04 13:26 |
| THuRStoN |
ArF 40€ por la sopa de roble :^)
No sé, a little bit overprized en ese rango se me ocurren mejores opciones. Pero al menos una vez seguro que está... |
- | 04/03/04 09:55 |
| Víctor Bcn |
Re: Jolin 40 euros ...
Disculpa Mª Jesús, pero con todo esto que comentas de tribunales etc... Me pierdo... Ya dirás las fechas en las que... |
- | 04/03/04 09:30 |
| MaJesus |
Jolin 40 euros ...
... me parece que esperare un buuuueeeeeen rato! andtes de probarlo! :-))) ... deseando estoy de ir a ;explorar; vila... |
- | 04/03/04 01:00 |
| Víctor Bcn |
Re: A mi sí! a mi sí!
No hace falta en V. Vila lo tienen a 40 €;. No recuerdo exactamente... Saludos. |
- | 04/03/04 00:52 |
Utilizamos cookies propias y de terceros con finalidades analíticas y para mostrarte publicidad relacionada con tus preferencias a partir de tus hábitos de navegación y tu perfil. Puedes configurar o rechazar las cookies haciendo click en “Configuración de cookies”. También puedes aceptar todas las cookies pulsando el botón “Aceptar”. Para más información puedes visitar nuestra Ver política de cookies.