Wine Forum > Parker & Robinson, maybe two sides of...

So sorry, Walt... Never had a crust on me. We Cubans of a certain extraction

<< Volver al mensaje 'So sorry, Walt... Never had a crust on me. We Cubans of a certain extraction'

#12
MCamblor
en respuesta a WaltZalenski

Who ya callin' "crusty?"

Ver mensaje de WaltZalenski

So sorry, Walt... Never had a crust on me. We Cubans of a certain extraction and persuasion have a thing for meticulous personal hygiene.

And I’m not saying that Mrs. Robinson has not put out her fair share of favorable assessments of wines I consider utterly impotable. But hey, at least that’s only part of the time. She does write wonderfully, which tends to soften my judgment a little (retired Comp Lit PhD type here), without the tacky repetitiveness of certain folks from Maryland. So, I’d still fight alongside her, as long as it’s a battle I believe worthy. Pavie, yes. Calvario? Hell no! I can fight a good fight, but never out of blind idolatry, believe me. And I will always question those who lead the charge (almost as hard as I question myself).

Oh, and I do believe some clarification is in order: My main objection to Mr. de Gregorio’s top wines is not related to their ";fruit"; component. As far as I can tell, my every note on those wines has had harshest comments for the drying, palate-lacerating levels of oak involved. Oh, well, and also the price.

Naturally, I would expect Mrs. Robinson to have swallowed some of the hype surrounding many of those costly Spanish New-wave concoctions I love to hate. If memory serves, her guide when she has toured Spain has been a certain portly gentleman of my acquaintance, a fine journalist who started his own winemaking concern not too long ago and whose writings often involve praise for precisely those wines. Know what I’m sayin’? Give Dante a guide who is passionate about the marketing of Hell and you’ll get a very rosy ";Inferno"; indeed...

Don’t believe da hype--it’s the sequel!

M.

M.

<< Volver al mensaje 'So sorry, Walt... Never had a crust on me. We Cubans of a certain extraction'

Cookies en verema.com

Utilizamos cookies propias y de terceros con finalidades analíticas y para mostrarte publicidad relacionada con tus preferencias a partir de tus hábitos de navegación y tu perfil. Puedes configurar o rechazar las cookies haciendo click en “Personalizar”. También puedes aceptar todas las cookies pulsando el botón “Aceptar”. Para más información puedes visitar nuestra Ver política de cookies.

Personalizar
Rechazar todas
Aceptar