Manuel, her scores (out of 20) are very clear: 18,5 (the maximum she awards,

Manuel, her scores (out of 20) are very clear: 18,5 (the maximum she awards, except for the 19/20 for the Ch. Montrose 2003), 17.5 and 16. These are high scores in my language. But sure, you don’t belive in scores as conveying any meaning... :-)

Regarding the TNs, ";Chewy, fine and absolutely no shortage of acidity."; seems like something nice. Or that ";Certainly the best kosher wine I have tasted though."; (perhaps she has tried only a very few :-)

And, yes, I agree that the TN of Virginie de Valandraud 2003 don’t invite to drink the wine (in spite of that 16 out of 20).