Are wine critics parasites????

Replies: 7
Reply this topic

<< Return to Wine forum
Paco-higon_thumbnail
Top 10

Paco Higón

12/05/08 11:57

Are wine critics parasites????

 

Yo can not miss this post from the blog Vinography:

http://www.vinography.com/archives/2008/04/wine_critics_are_parasites_but.html

I'd like to know your opinion....

Verema.com

Reply this message

 
jose
Top 10

jose

12/05/08 21:28

Replies to:

Are they anything without...

 

the wineries and (disinformed) wine drinkers? Hmmm.... yes... a sort of parasites with a strong symbiotical face linked to wineries ;)

Regards,

Jose

Reply this message

 
rikiwigley
Top 25

rikiwigley

13/05/08 09:07

Replies to:

Re: Wine parasites?

 

Well, if Jancis says so there must be something in it!

I feel this is just a good example of exagerating to make a point.After all wine makers need their parasites as they get lots of free publicity from wine journalists. I suspect it is a minor irritation and someone has to do the job!

Riki

Reply this message

 
suiko
Top 25

suiko

13/05/08 10:10

Replies to:

Re: Wine parasites?

 

Winemakers are the cows (or maybe hippos?) and wine writers the cattle egrets.

Reply this message

 
Verema_thumbnail
Top 10

Verema

13/05/08 17:47

Replies to:

So.. at the end....

 

everyone agrees!!!

Reply this message

 
jose
Top 10

jose

13/05/08 20:31

Replies to:

But... what's really the job?

 

Telling what to drink? Well, it would be a kind of Shangri-La if we accept that's true, but we have to admit that their wage come from the same wineries that place nice advertising in the magazin they are working for... There're too many money streams on it, in this "industry" to see no other thing that interested actors. But hey! what's the problem being a parasite? I find none. Every "biological" life form has a reason to exist, isn't it? ;)

Regards,

Jose

Reply this message

 
suiko
Top 25

suiko

16/05/08 15:55

Replies to:

Re: But... what's really the job?

 

Particularly in the Internet age, when most of us have become quite skilled at finding endless sources of opinion and taking them all with a large pinch of salt!

Reply this message

 
<< Return to Wine forum
Versión para imprimir